New client onboarding offer — first month of Managed IT 50% offCode: AZM50 Claim it →
AZ MANAGEDIT Free Assessment

/ Security

How to Turn On MFA for Every Microsoft 365 User (Including the Awkward Accounts)

Multi-factor authentication stops most account takeovers. How to roll it out in Microsoft 365 with Security Defaults or Conditional Access, and what to do about shared mailboxes, old apps and admins.

By Joe, founder & lead engineerUpdated 2 min read

Most business email compromises start with a stolen password. Multi-factor authentication (MFA) means a password alone is not enough to get in, and it is the first control every cyber insurer asks about.

Two ways to turn it on

  • Security Defaults (free, all plans): one switch that requires MFA registration for everyone, requires MFA for admins and blocks legacy sign-in protocols. Good for very small offices with simple needs.
  • Conditional Access (Microsoft Entra ID P1, included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium): rules such as "require MFA everywhere except trusted office devices" or "block sign-ins from outside the US". More flexible, and the right choice once you have more than a handful of people.

You use one or the other: Security Defaults has to be turned off before Conditional Access policies take over.

A rollout that does not flood your help desk

  1. Pick the method: the Microsoft Authenticator app with number matching is the best balance of security and ease. Avoid SMS codes where you can.
  2. Tell staff a week ahead, with screenshots of what they will see.
  3. Start with admins and the office manager, then everyone else.
  4. Have someone available on rollout day to help with phones.

The awkward accounts

  • Shared logins (front@, scanner@): convert to shared mailboxes, which do not have their own sign-in, and give people access through their own accounts.
  • Scanners and copiers that email scans: use a dedicated SMTP relay or connector rather than a user account with MFA turned off.
  • Old apps and phones that only support basic authentication: Microsoft has turned basic authentication off for Exchange Online, so these need modern apps anyway.
  • Break-glass admin: keep one emergency Global Admin account with a long, stored password and strong MFA, excluded from location rules, so you cannot lock yourself out.
Then check it worked: the Entra ID sign-in logs show which sign-ins used MFA. Look for any account still signing in with a single factor.

MFA is step one of our cybersecurity baseline for every managed client.

/ Next step

Rather have an
engineer do it?

Tell us where you are with this and we will tell you what it takes, what it costs, and whether you can do it yourself.

  • Free 15-minute call with an engineer
  • Straight answer on what we’d fix first
  • Flat monthly price, month-to-month

Free · no obligation

Talk to an engineer today

Leave a name and number. A real engineer calls you back, not a sales rep.

Or call (480) 764-5475 · Mon–Fri

/ Talk to us

Tell us what
needs looking after.

Rough is fine. A quick note about your setup and the biggest headache is enough for us to be useful on the first call.

(480) 764-5475

Headquartered in Gilbert, AZ · on-site across the Phoenix East Valley, remote across Arizona, New Mexico, California & Texas. Support hours Mon–Fri, after-hours cover for managed clients.

GilbertMesaChandlerTempeScottsdaleQueen CreekPhoenixGlendalePeoriaSurpriseFlagstaffPrescottTucsonAlbuquerqueSanta FeRio RanchoLas CrucesGallupFarmingtonCaliforniaTexas
None selected

Straight to an engineer. No newsletter, no sales sequence.

AZ MANAGEDIT

Managed IT, cybersecurity and cloud for businesses across Arizona, New Mexico, Texas and California. Headquartered in Gilbert, AZ.

(480) 764-5475 [email protected]

Core

Infrastructure

Growth & apps

Who we help

Company